so, with out further ado, here are the films id like to win:
having seen (almost) all the films nominated, i must admit that they are all quite good. 'michael clayton' was a thrilling lawyer drama, 'juno' was a bright breath of fresh air, 'no country for old men' was a powerful look at a killer. i didnt bother seeing 'atonement' because it looked stupid, even an oscar nomination will not change that. but, all these weeks later, it is 'there will be blood' that still lingers, it still haunts with its stark landscape and brooding portrait of a man who wants it all at any cost.
this is a little harder one to pick. the truth of the matter is that if a director is really good you dont notice. i didnt notice what it was about 'no country for old men' that made the film engaging, but i do know that each scene was always elegantly shot and never confused in its setup or execution of its scenes. i guess that would qualify as good directing.
'there will be blood' was an amazing film, but it does not gain its power from its story. all the power of the film comes, rather, from the portrayal of the oil man at its center. the delivery is so different than anything else seen lately. the cadence and delivery of the lines by day-lewis alone demands your utmost attention. it is almost impossible to take your eyes off of him when he is on the screen. this role proves that acting is truly an art form.
the cultural phenomenon that is 'juno' can be placed almost entirely in the lap of ellen page. she is such a natural fit at playing this role. it almost seems as if she isnt acting at all, but rather this is what she is actually like (which after seeing interviews with her might actually be the case...). she was able to take a really heavy story of teen pregnancy and turn it into an uplifting tale of growing up and accepting what may come. much of the credit for this can also be put on diablo cody, the author of the screenplay, but ellen page brings it to such magnificent life that her impact cannot be dismissed.
his portrayal of robert ford stole the whole show in a movie staring one of the biggest stars out there today- brad pitt. his nervous loser of a character in 'the assassination of jesse james by the coward robert ford' was totally fleshed out and believable as someone who is star struck by his hero, but is unable to stand along side of him. he wants so hard to be a member of jesse's posse, but is too awkward and introverted to ever really be a hero himself. casey affleck was able to show all this through his portrayal. a remarkable feat.
her performance in 'michael clayton' is the only one of the nominated women who i saw. she did a great job as a lawyer who is representing a company that is disposing poisonous waste. she does a great job of showing the strength needed to be that lawyer, but also allows us to see her own private weakness when she is trying to prepare for the big presentations. the final showdown with clooney is powerful and satisfying.
other than that, i would say that 'no country for old men' is worthy of the adapted screenplay oscar, and 'juno' should end the night with a win for original screenplay.
again, i'm not saying that these films and actors will win, but they definitely should.